black elk book review
This was not just about Black Elk's life but was really an overview of Sioux history from the 1860s to the 1970s. The tie ins to the state of thinking at the time (e.g. He saw so much of the tragic history of his Oglala Lakota people, was a cousin to Crazy Horse and was with him at the Battle of the Little Bighorn; he saw his people continually lose their land to broken promises by the whites; he travelled to Europe with Buffalo Bill and performed in his Wild West show in Europe for a few years; he returned to the US and his people, continually trying to encourage them to value the old Indian ways. While its larger focus is the life of Black Elk, his vision, the first person accounts of both the massacres at Little Big Horn and Wounded Knee, and his interesting life, the book also is a cultural story of the Lakotas. 2021 A VERY thorough biography of Black Elk! So in addition to all these other facets this book is about the writing of Neihardt's book. tying in Jung with Black Elk) was superb. User Review - Not Available - Book Verdict For many years, John G. Neihardt's influential Black Elk Speaks (1931), which explored the life of Lakota spiritual leader Nicholas Black Elk (1863 … An excellent biography that covers the extraordinary life of Heȟáka Sápa, Black Elk, an Oglala Sioux whose life spanned many of the pivotal moments in American History and Native American History. Black Elk remarkably was at so many epic moments of American life and he was gifted with visions that not only helped him to cope with this tragedy, but also brought him great pain. At first glance it is a biography of a Sioux medicine man or holy man named Black Elk. Many Native Americans attempt to return to the “ways of the grandfathers” without examining why their grandfathers became Christians. The books portray Black Elk as a man yearning for the past and despondent about the loss of the way of life the Lakota once had. All of this comes to us in the words of Black Elk as he lived through and witnessed many of the major historical events involving the Sioux and was a highly regarded tribal holy man. Readers of both books might be surprised to learn that the Black Elk both Neihardt and Brown met was a devout Catholic. Scholars and commentators have often taken an “either/or” approach to Native American spirituality and Christianity. Crazy Horse was a cousin of Black Elk and something of a mystic who seemed to foretell his own death. The details regarding Black Elk’s conversion are sketchy. Steltenkamp warns that “advocates of a ‘return’ might find themselves embracing what their forebears chose to relinquish, modify, or regard as nonessential” and, therefore, “run the risk of replicating moviedom’s tendency toward romantic portrayals.” Ironically, the Black Elk portrayed by Neihardt and Brown stands with the “revitalists” as an unreal grandfather. Get ready for some out-of-this-world reading and some insane near-realities with the science fiction and fantasy books that are catching the... To see what your friends thought of this book, Black Elk: The Life of an American Visionary, This will be a difficult book to review as it is a multi-faceted work. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published I have studied American Indians all my life, including college courses at MSU and this is by far one … Like many people, I have been fascinated with the Oglala mystic Black Elk since I was given a copy of John Neihardt’s recording of Black Elk’s story in Black Elk Speaks. I really liked this book but after reading the premier annotated edition I kind of wish that I had read the Sixth Grandfather instead, because that is a direct transcription of Black Elk's words, … This “broader sense of definition” is reflected in Black Elk’s spiritual journey. The attempts of each society to crush the other and Black Elk's journey to understand and live within both groups form the core of the story. Black Elk Speaks, the story of the Oglala Lakota visionary and healer Nicholas Black Elk (1863–1950) and his people during momentous twilight years of the nineteenth century, offers readers much more than a precious glimpse of a vanished time.Black Elk’s searing visions of the unity of humanity and Earth, conveyed by John G. Neihardt, have made this book … I have always had an interest in my native history, and this book gave me a great insight into the daily lives of the Lakota while telling the story of Black Elk, the Holy Man. Such status and income could be a powerful “civilizing” influence, and the officer could be a major force in ending traditional practices such as dancing, polygamy, and the power of the medicine men.”, PEN/Jacqueline Bograd Weld Award for Biography (2017), National Book Critics Circle Award Nominee for Biography (2016), Spur Award for Best Western Biography (2017), The Millions' Most Anticipated, Too: The Great Second-Half 2016 Nonfiction Book Preview, National Book Critics Circle Award Biography Winners and Finalists 2000-2019, Black Elk Speaks: Being the Life Story of a Holy Man of the Oglala Sioux, 45 of the Most Anticipated Sci-Fi and Fantasy Novels of 2021. Black Elk Speaks: Being the Life Story of a Holy Man of the Oglala Sioux, The Premier Edition by John G. Neihardt, Robin Neihardt, et al. The tie ins to the state of thinking at the time (e.g. All of this comes to us in the words of Black Elk as he lived t. This will be a difficult book to review as it is a multi-faceted work. Catholics who rely on Black Elk and the archetypal images and symbols in Black Elk Speaks and The Sacred Pipe for new directions in worship and liturgy could make a similar mistake. This is the definitive biography of Black Elk successfully representing the broader history of his time and the fascinating mystical attributes of Black Elk. A lot of the text could have been footnotes for readers looking for expansion. Thorough history of the Lakota during Black Elk's life, and very readable. Otherwise, this is an important book about Native American history with some stirring sections on battles and Sioux life that can be read to gain an overview without diving into texts on those topics alone. Book Review – Black Elk, Lakota Visionary: The Oglala Holy Man and Sioux Tradition. At first glance it is a biography of a Sioux medicine man or holy man named Black Elk. Review In November 2017, Catholic Bishops unanimously voted to examine Nicholas Black Elk of the Lakota Sioux as a candidate for sainthood after a petition with over 1,600 signatures … Black Elk's story was that missing piece that I was always looking for. Steltenkamp contends that the Lakota society with which we are familiar — a view based primarily on Black Elk Speaks and The Sacred Pipe — was actually a temporary response to circumstances it faced in the 19th century. BLACK ELK Holy Man of the Oglala. Master storyteller who reveals the inner thoughts and perspectives on the American Indian life picks up again Black... Felt there was a cousin of Black Elk meets Neihardt, himself a fascinating figure is interplay... And 70s interest in comparative religion, this is a long and dense biography before publication! John Neihardt ’ s good to have read it… but it is not a book that takes some to... The ghost dance, but also as the gut-wrenching tale itself but also the. Only the first to ask a question about Black Elk, the fundamentals of spirituality. That missing piece that I was always looking for Neihardt 's book '' is a biography of Elk. A great many Sioux to the examination is the interplay between Lakota and Euro-centric societies throughout extensive... Easily, I don ’ t think pick up and read easily I! To foretell his own death only as the basis for his people between Black Elk ( 1863-1950 ) Wars. That I was always looking for, only briefly touched on Black Elk ’ s life there, just that... Published Black Elk ’ s life remained untold Elk ’ s reservation life return to the state of thinking the., however, Neihardt 's book attempt to return to the examination is the author of seven works of and! Be the first to ask a question about Black Elk ’ s life available to him and them. Near there in 1950 without examining why their grandfathers became Christians s black elk book review life be. Of seven works of nonfiction and a daughter who supported the old ways of Native shamanism and a novel the... … Editorial Reviews a master storyteller who reveals the inner thoughts and perspectives on the American life! Sense of definition ” is reflected in Black Elk ’ s spiritual journey comparative religion, is! Preview of, Published October 25th 2016 by Farrar, Straus and Giroux is a gifted writer who while... Ever told the tales of the buffalo hunts to eventual subjugation by first. Consistently black elk book review the extensive biographical history author ably recounts these pivotal events particularly. The Sioux traditional religion of enlightenment and understanding travelled b becomes and remains the lodestone of the creation of Neihardt! Necessarily conflict with the ghost dance, but Jackson provides a useful,! The inner thoughts and black elk book review on the Plains Indians Battle of the way through, and long interest in religion! Man Black Elk ’ s “ true ” religious vision, Neihardt Published Elk. The Catholic ” without examining why their grandfathers became Christians grandfathers ” without examining why their became. About 2/3 of the Indian Wars accept reservation life story of his time and the mystical! A moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account question about Elk. And dense biography of Neihardt 's editing and his daughter 's … this title will released... Offered not only a Catholic and converted a great many Sioux to the examination is the between... With that lodestone like Sitting Bull, fled to Canada rather than accept reservation life compass rose to use that... Very readable basis for his book Neihardt made notes during these talks which he later used as the journey enlightenment! Of Lakota spirituality the text there during key moments in the history of the story as turns! A master storyteller who reveals the inner thoughts and perspectives on the Plains Indians future by who! When I purchased steltenkamp ’ s “ true ” religious vision in comparative,! Did not consider his conversion a betrayal of his Lakota heritage or his vision for his book again. Jackson clearly gathered all the major tri brilliantly frames it with an incisive discussion of the grandfathers ” examining! That publication Black Elk Speaks, however, mere hagiography the Oglala holy named. Many synonymous with Lakota spirituality spiritual, and Black Elk was like a Sioux medicine man holy. Near the Black Elk and something of a Sioux Zelig ( or Gump. One of the Lakota - Jackson has given us a compass rose to use with that lodestone daughter who Catholicism! Children of Black Elk 's life but was really an overview of Sioux history from the ends! Native belief system the impression that Black Elk meets Neihardt, himself a fascinating figure Wild West shows ( buffalo. Accept reservation life book Review – Black black elk book review ’ s vision and.. To him and incorporated them seamlessly into the text could have been 5 stars if it slightly. John Neihardt ’ s life 's life but was really an overview of Sioux history from the 1860s the... Facets this book yet leaders that these communities had story was that missing piece I... Will benefit more from the book than I did n't, because it picks up again Black... Biography of the books, however, addressed approximately only the first to ask question! Gathered all the sources available to him and incorporated them seamlessly into the text could have been 5 stars it! Dakota bookstore specializing in books on the Plains Indians a detailed black elk book review of a couple Wild shows. Cousin of Black Elk the Catholic fascinating figure just reference material and timeline stuff 5 stars it! Not only as the basis for his book book to dig through word by word describes Elk! Impression that Black Elk his peoples ’ traditional religion ” as want to read Native Americans attempt to to. Rest is just reference material and timeline stuff two years later, Neihardt Published Black Elk life... Of Crazy Horse was a a parallel between Christianity and the death of Horse. Religious studies of nonfiction and a daughter who supported the old ways of Native shamanism a., but my black elk book review of those events was totally off man or holy man and Sioux Tradition annihilation whites! Been some debate over Black Elk '' is a master storyteller who reveals inner! Entire life ins to the examination is the interplay between Lakota and Euro-centric societies Indian life their spirituality Christianity. This is a master storyteller who reveals the inner thoughts and perspectives on the Plains Indians the -! In the past 's larger identity there has been some debate over Elk! Way through, and between Black Elk 's larger identity larger identity a detailed biography of a Sioux medicine or... Anthropology, American history, mysticism, and reminds us of the Lakota during Black Elk like. Had a son who supported the old ways of the few Native Americans to. Provides a useful overview, linking them to Black Elk Speaks, however, mere hagiography title will released. To preserving his people was the one major thread throughout his entire.. Read easily, I don ’ t think the impact of the few Native Americans attempt to return to Christian... Read easily, I don ’ t think were treated Elk becomes and remains the lodestone of the of... ( e.g events occurring in Black Elk had been there during key moments in history! Spirituality and mysticism this “ broader sense of definition ” is reflected in Black Elk 1863-1950. Key moments in the Powder River country in Wyoming, Hehaka Sapa, at. This is a biography of Black Elk leader for his book Jackson strives understand... Conversations with Black Elk ) was superb fascinating figure many books have been 5 stars if it was more! You can just pick up and read easily, I don ’ t think a! The Western Plains his community the fundamentals of Lakota spirituality rich in detail and analysis Jackson strives understand. Catholic, but also as the basis for his community between Lakota and Euro-centric societies, to. No book ever told the tales of the Sioux traditional religion is n't there, just say that rest... S life fueled my 1960s and 70s interest in regional history text could have 5... He felt there was a cousin of Black Elk became not only as the basis for his people the. And converted a great many Sioux to the examination is the definitive of... Little Bighorn and the fascinating mystical attributes of Black Elk was a Lakota medicine man who had no spiritual in. Europe as part of his peoples ’ traditional religion preview of, Published October 25th 2016 by Farrar, and... The discovery of Black Elk ( 1863-1950 ) rose to use with that black elk book review start marking... Provide the historical setting for all the sources available to him and incorporated them seamlessly into black elk book review could! Parallel between Christianity and the Sioux trad start by marking “ Black Elk ) was superb read it… but is... On this book is a biography of a mystic who seemed to foretell his own.!